My Mariposa festival experience did not get off to what you'd call a great start. I knew traffic was going to be a bitch, competing with Friday afternoon cottage traffic, but I'd had Richard F. check the time on the first set I cared about, and I was confident I could make the drive to Orillia in time to get there. And indeed, after a 3 and a half hour drive (normally less than 2), I did manage to get to the festival site about 15 minutes before Serena Ryder's set was scheduled to start, whereupon the nice parking man informed me that it had been raining for some three straight hours in Orillia that afternoon and the show had been washed out. I turned around and made the hour and half drive home. Checking the website over the weekend, I discovered that I had been misinformed, and that, in fact, the mainstage show had been moved to the beer tent, not cancelled entirely. My aggravation over missing it is immense.
The next morning, after several hours of Feelin' Hot, Hot, Hot and Crocodile Rockin' at the IBM corporate picnic, I was anxious to make the return trip North for day 2, if for no other reason than to drive the horrible, horrible music out of my brain. It was late in the day and after I arrived and looked around for awhile to get an idea of how things were set up and went back to my car and got a chair and whatever else, there was only one round of small stage performances left. I opted for a concert by a duo called "Likewater" on the Estelle Klein stage. Good, catchy, well-written lyrics, if a little spare on the music side. I picked up their CD which is less spare, and which I quite like.
The evening line-up on Saturday night was Crooked Still (bluegrass fusion, of a sorts), La Corde du Bois (Quebec traditionalist kitchen party), David Francey (story-telling songwriter), Fruit (Australian pop folk) and Tom Cochrane (Uh, Tom Cochrane ?!?).
I enjoyed Crooked Still a fair bit, though not enough to buy a CD. They seem like a 'see them live' band to me. I didn't really think much of La Corde du Bois one way or the other. They were fine, I suppose. David Francey is one of those singer-songwriters who can't stand to let his songs tell the story. He has to preface every song with a five minute explanation of where it came from and what it's about. Fortunately, he's a reasonably funny kind of guy so this wasn't completely bloody annoying. Fruit (there's some weird capitalization thing in there that I decline to participate in) were energetic and fun and had quirky Australian accents. They were a little on the rah, rah, is everyone out there having fun, I can't hear you side in terms of on stage mannerisms, but musically, they were pretty solid.
Tom Cochrane was an interesting closer. Not exactly someone you'd think of as a "folk" artist, he's a pretty straight forward Canadian rocker, but with sufficiently solid songwriting chops that he fit in pretty well with the rest of the line-up. The show was a real nostalgia trip for me, because my very first concert ever, was Tom Cochrane on Canada Day of 1990 at a big outdoor show in a field. I've always enjoyed his music, and the show at Mariposa was no exception. It suffered some from what I think of as old dog - old tricks syndrome. Artists have been singing the same songs for so damned long that they get bored with them. In order to not be bored with them, they try new arrangements, new phrasing, new whatever to make them seem like they aren't the same damned songs they were singing 15 years ago. This is not always, or even generally, a good idea. A few different songs that night were really badly mangled in the new arrangements. Without the sheer volume of chatter put out by David Francey, Tom managed to introduce the songs and tell interesting stories about them. I'd have liked to have heard Life is a Highway, but 20 minutes after the show was expected to end, it was still going on strong, and I had a nearly 2 hour drive home that night, so I departed.
The next morning, I headed back up North for another day. After lunching with a friend in Barrie, I arrived in time to catch the last song of a workshop featuring Lynn Miles, Lennie Gallant and Russell de Carle. That one song alone was worth the price of admission, and I'm damned sorry I missed the rest of that set.
The next workshop was another really fine one - Fred Eaglesmith, Gurf Morlix and Murray McLauchlan - set up a 'swapping stories and telling lies' kind of vibe. It was like watching a bunch of guys on a back porch somewhere, and they were really strong together, trading licks and backing each other up.
Followed that up with a workshop featuring Trio Bravo, Oh Susanna and Serena Ryder, that was a weaker example of what a workshop could be. While Serena and the Trio eventually worked their way into each other's grooves, and were playing along, Oh Susanna seemed completely detached from the group. She didn't kick in on anyone else's songs, she seemed uncomfortable when they played in on hers. She's one of my favourite artists, so I still enjoyed her songs, but I'd have liked to see her do something with the group as a whole.
If the Trio/Oh/Serena workshop was a poor example of what a workshop could be, the last workshop I saw that day was an unmitigated disaster. A mix of the Sweet Water Women, Serena Ryder and Bleeker Ridge was like oil and water and a different kind of oil. Sweet Water Women is traditionalist native folk singing, Serena Ryder is a folk singer-songwriter with a powerful voice, Bleeker Ridge is a teeny-bopper rock band. They had nothing in common and nothing to work with each other on. Even the stage set-up was bad, because as they took turns, they'd go up to the mics, then return to their chairs at the back of the stage while others sang, there wasn't even an opportunity for collaboration, really. I've talked about Serena Ryder before, and can't say enough good things about her, she really is a hell of a singer. Sweet Water Women do a style of music that alternately moves me completely and bores me to death, depending on the power of the performance. This was relatively low key stuff that definitely fell on the bores me to death end of things. For a pack of Junior High kids, Bleeker Ridge is a surprisingly good band. They need a few years of seasoning, especially when it comes to stage confidence, but they're pretty decent at what they do - sort of like a Hanson that doesn't suck. Together, though, the workshop was a disconnected mess.
Sunday evening's lineup was Harry Manx, Fred Eaglesmith, Lynn Miles, Murray McLauchlan and Gordon Lightfoot. I'd already decided in advance that I was leaving after Lynn Miles set because I needed to finish a document for work that night, which meant not staying for Gordon Lightfoot's set, and I'm not much in the way of a Murray McLauchlan fan, so couldn't see staying for that, either.
I have no idea what Harry Manx was doing up there, but I really wish he'd been doing it somewhere else. Out of earshot. Fred Eaglesmith was funny and interesting and worthwhile, and I'm not quite sure why I spent several years thinking I didn't like him. I must have been mixing him up with someone else. Lynn Miles did an excellent set, and I've been wanting to hear her for awhile. I often find it difficult to get into songs I don't know at concerts, but Lynn's set was really good, despite my lack of prior knowledge.
Overall, a good weekend, well worth the cost of the tickets, though the cost of 4 hours a day of driving is questionable. In the future, I'd probably find a way to afford to stay in Orillia to bring that time commitment down.
Relevent Links:
Mariposa Folk Festival